Saturday, April 25, 2009

Opportunity not fantasy for blogs

By Harold McIlvain II

It isn’t a paying job.

But University of Arkansas junior Matt Watson treats it as if it was. He watches games, adds and drops players and looks for trades. He is a fantasy baseball general manager.

And he isn’t alone.

Fantasy Sports Ventures estimates 15 million Americans play fantasy sports, each spending an average of $154 per year on fantasy games and related products.

With large companies like ESPN and Yahoo providing to the majority of the market place, smaller Web sites are looking find a place in the business.

On a daily basis, Watson checks smaller Web sites to help find treads and statistics to get an advantage over his fantasy league opponents.

“To stay completely informed, you have to have a lot of different sources of information,” Watson said. “You can go to the big sites and read all the stats you want. But people usually don’t have time to evaluate week by week stuff by players.”

Enter opportunity.

“Big sports sites can’t be everything to everybody,” said Rudy Gamble, a Razzball.com fantasy baseball writer. “Users seem to be increasingly more comfortable going ‘off the reservation’ for content.”

After launching the Web site last year, Gamble said it picked up momentum as the baseball year went along. But with a new season already underway, Razzball is doing even better with advertising and views, Gamble said.

“By the time pre-season started, we were hitting all-time highs as we had a core following,” Gamble said. “We were showing up higher in search listings, and we were linked on some big sites like Deadspin and SI’s Extra Mustard.”

But Gamble said the Web site has tempered expectations.

“Success is relative in the world of blogs - particularly something as niche as fantasy baseball,” Gamble said. “While some blogs have monthly audiences over 1 million, fantasy baseball blogdom is still a bit underground thanks to many people never leaving the friendly confines of their league host.”

Despite not being near the size of the competition, Gamble said Razzball tries to fill a niche by providing people a greater sense of community.

“The message boards on ESPN and Yahoo are so big,” Gamble said. “People are looking for an edge over their competition.”

R.J. White, a fantasy baseball writer for the Fantasy Baseball Cafe, said the community element is very important for the Web site.

“It is the backbone of the cafe,” White said. “Members first come here looking for fantasy information and stay because they love the great community we have here.”

With over tens of thousands of registered members on the Web site message board, the Fantasy Baseball Cafe tries to offer different areas for users to keep coming back, White said.

“A lot of people join the Cafe and find themselves all over different parts of it,” White said. “But soon they settle into their own niche. The element of community is the biggest, most critical element in drawing in and retaining users.”

But the market of providing fantasy baseball information isn’t new.

The Web site BaseballHQ.com has provided articles and statistics since 1986. Unlike other Web pages, users can subscribe to the services with three month plans starting at $39.

“Baseball HQ carved out a high-end fantasy niche before the major media sites even acknowledged fantasy as a valid content area,” said Ray Murphy, managing editor of the Web site. “Our market remains the serious fantasy player who recognize the value added of paying for the exclusive tools.”

Murphy said Baseball HQ provides advanced tools, strategies and concepts that other sites don’t offer.

“We have a long track record of success and a dedicated core audience,” Murphy said.

But Zack Cimini, a 2007 graduate of Arizona State, said the market still has room for further growth.

“Fantasy sports is one of the fastest booming industries around,” said Cimini, who is opening a fantasy Web site. “The trends also show most fans spend two-to-three hours a week scouring sites with information.”

The New York native said since large providers took a couple of years to get into the information giving part of fantasy sports, smaller Web site can fill the void.

"Small businesses still have a good share of the market,” Cimini said.

1 comment:

  1. Harold,

    I like the general idea, and you've done some good reporting, but this piece still has a ways to go. The structure isn't working and it's taking too long for you to get to the heart of the story: inroads made by niche fantasy sites. Part of the problem is using a fantasy player to tell your story. WAtson doesn't illustrate this angle. He illustrates the popularity of fantasy in general. But that's not what this story is about.

    Also, we need more examples of niche fantasy publications than Razzball and some guy who may or may not start one. We should get at least three existing niche sites, with explanations of how they serve a unique market that ESPN or Yahoo is missing. And then you can use the Arizona State guy as an example of how people still see room for further growth.

    See specific comments below:

    I like the lede, but I'm not sure Watson is the best fit -- unless he subscribes to the smaller fantasy Web sites you're writing about.

    You may want to open the story with someone who has created a niche fantasy Web site. You can establish the basics of fantasy sports (as you do with Watson) and the popularity (with your numbers) a touch later in the story.

    The nut graf is fine, but in the very next graf it seems you're backing up and circling back to where you were with Watson. Instead, move us deeper into the angle of the story, the small fantasy enterprises.

    This is the problem:
    --With large companies like ESPN and Yahoo providing to the majority of the market place, smaller Web sites are looking find a place in the business.

    Watson, who has played for four years, said fantasy baseball is growing into a mainstream level of popularity.

    'used'
    It use to be

    I'm going to quibble with this. Fantasy has been around a long time, and with 15 million users, that means it's already in the mainstream. Also, why would this year be the year? Why not last year or the year before that? Has something changed?

    --Watson, who has played for four years, said fantasy baseball is growing into a mainstream level of popularity.

    “I think this is the year where people are saying fantasy baseball is here,” Watson said

    Don't get this:
    --It use to be something people use to do.

    need teams, positions. Also, how does trading a surging player for a declining player help you win a championship?
    --Last year, Watson traded a surging Josh Hamilton for a declining CC Sabathia to help him win his league championship.

    It's taking too long to get to the point of your story, which is niche fantasy sites. Using a fantasy player (Watson) to help tell this piece is a good idea, but I don't think it's working here. The story is bogging down in too much explanation and making it difficult for you to transition to the real theme of the story.

    We need to get to this guy and Razzball sooner. Also, tell us more about why he thought there was opportunity in a fantasy world dominated by ESPN and Yahoo. How old is Gamble? How did he get interested in this? where is he located?

    --“Big sports sites can’t be everything to everybody,” said Rudy Gamble, a Razzball.com fantasy baseball writer. “Users seem to be increasingly more comfortable going ‘off the reservation’ for content.”

    Need specifics here. How much better?
    Razzball is doing even better with advertising and views, Gamble said.

    story is wandering a bit. Think about structure. And stay on topic.
    --But Gamble said new users are not the only sign of development in fantasy baseball participation.

    “A lot of the growth probably is coming from people who went from recreational player in one league to hardcore players in three-to-five leagues,” Gamble said

    You quote Watson as an expert, but he's only a fantasy player. That undermines the credibility of your story and his quotes. So, use WAtson as an example of a hard-core player. Use an expert to give you expert opinion about the industry.

    I'll send your preliminary grade in an email.

    ReplyDelete