By Harold McIlvain II
The Fayetteville Equipment Committee supported the purchase of four vehicles for the city Wednesday but denied two other vehicle proposals.
The committee approved one truck apiece to the airport and building safety divisions while also approving two trucks to the water and sewer division.
But a request for a four-wheel-drive truck for the meter division and a crew cab truck for the police department were opposed.
Robert Ferrell, chairperson of the committee, said he felt a four-wheel-drive truck for the meter division wasn’t needed.
“It’s just like I’ve talked about with our two mile-per-gallon trash trucks,” Ferrell said. “If we are green, we need to walk the walk and talk the talk. Four-wheel drive costs more up front. There is more mileage and maintenance involved, too.”
Dennis Pratt, superintendent of maintenance, said the division - which currently has 19 vehicles - has tried to cut four-wheel-drive trucks to 50 percent of the workforce over the last few years.
But Pratt said the need for the more versatile vehicle is still needed during inclement weather.
“When there is bad weather, they still need to get around to the meters,” Pratt said.
Ferrell said he wasn’t against four-wheel-drive trucks, but he felt a two-wheel-drive truck would be just as efficient.
“We do understand there are instances when four-wheel drives are needed,” Ferrell said. “But sometimes we need to efficiently deploy different units. It’s economical and environmentally friendly. We need to spend taxpayers’ money responsibly.”
Pratt wasn’t surprised the committee approved the purchase of a two-wheel drive for the division rather than a four-wheel drive.
“I knew coming in that four-wheel drive was always an issue,” Pratt said. “This is what we do and is apart of the process.”
A vote was delayed on the approval of a crew cab truck for the police department to allow the police chief an opportunity to make a case for the need for a crew cab.
Ferrell said he believed the truck didn’t necessary need to have a crew cab on a truck that wouldn’t be used nearly as much as a patrol car despite the advantages it would bring.
“Although it is a good use for that truck to be able to show new mothers how to install baby seats and to work large events, I feel we need to look at efficiency,” Ferrell said.
Pratt said the truck would be able to transport four fully geared police officers along with signs used for football games. By using the truck, the department would not be using a patrol car that could be put to use for normal duties, Pratt said.
But Ferrell said the extended cab was an issue.
“I think it makes sense to save taxpayers’ money of an extended cab and use the patrol cars to haul the rest of the people down there,” Ferrell said. “They are going there anyway. When there is a large event, there are a lot of police officers around anyway.”
With each new vehicle purchase, an older one is traded in. And with the economy impacting funds, committee member Shirley Lucas said it is even more important now to fully inspect the trucks that are being replaced.
“I just try to point out that we might be able to look at the conditions of the trucks a little closer with the economy in its current situation,” Lucas said. “When people asked for something, it [used] to be rubber stamped. But things have changed. We use to have lots of money.”
But the process is improving with a new program that will help track the conditions of automobiles.
The program that will be on the budget in June will establish a full history of every vehicle. Using factors of miles, age of car, maintenance history and personal driver opinions, the program will be able to see which vehicle needs to be replaced first.
“We have improved a lot on replacing cars,” Lucas said. “We use to have a process where just in a set amount of years a vehicle was replaced, whether it was in need of replace or not. But even with your own vehicle, you have to evaluate. You can’t just trade it out.”
But despite the disagreements regarding what needed to be replaced, Lucas said the committee was pleased the lowest bids came from two local vendors in Fayetteville, Ark., and Springdale, Ark.
“We always hope to buy locally,” Lucas said. “We are encouraged when we do. Keeping the money in our area just makes sense.”
With the auto industry down in sales, Pratt said the city received nearly six bids for every vehicle.
“They really sharpened their pencils quite a bit with very competitive bids,” Pratt said. “It really has helped us out. The amount of bidders was surprising.”
Saturday, April 4, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Harold,
ReplyDeleteOverall very nicely done. Your lede is clean and to the point, but it's missing the time element What day? And the overall structure of the story is good, with the most important, broad strokes up top, and the smaller details, quotes, etc., filling up the rest of the piece.
Some inexcusable spelling errors here, though.
See specific comments below:
when? -- The Fayetteville Equipment Committee supported the purchase of four vehicles for the city but denied two other vehicle proposals.
This is just sloppy. Use spellcheck: was apposed, superindent
good exchange: But Pratt said the need for the more versatile vehicle is still needed during inclement weather.
“When there is bad weather, they still need to get around to the meters,” Pratt said.
Ferrell said he wasn’t against four-wheel-drive trucks, but he felt a two-wheel-drive truck would be just as efficient.
“We do understand there are instances when four-wheel drives are needed,” Ferrell said. “But sometimes we need to efficiently deploy different units. It’s economical and environmentally friendly. We need to spend taxpayers’ money responsibly.”
Pratt wasn’t surprised the committee approved the purchase of a two-wheel drive for the division rather than a four-wheel drive.
“I knew coming in that four-wheel drive was always an issue,” Pratt said. “This is what we do and is apart of the process.”
fix: it use to be
be a little more specific--
With the auto industry being in its current condition,
good details --
But the process is improving with a new program that will help track the conditions of automobiles.
The program that will be on the budget in June will establish a full history of every vehicle. Using factors of miles, age of car, maintenance history and personal driver opinions, the program will be able to see which vehicle needs to be replaced first
I'll send your preliminary grade in an email. I look forward to seeing the final draft.